Some houses just have a presence. The moment you see the steeply pitched slate roof, the pointed arch windows, and the decorative trim on this 1870 Victorian Gothic Revival in Poultney, Vermont, it’s easy to understand why it has already pulled in nearly 14,000 views and over 1,270 saves since hitting the market on August 4, 2026 — just 17 days ago.
The Numbers
Listed at $319,900, the home works out to about $161 per square foot, with an estimated monthly payment around $2,367. Annual property taxes run $4,266, against a tax assessment of $174,600. For a home with this much architectural pedigree in a walkable New England village, that price point is drawing serious attention — and the traffic numbers back it up.
A True Gothic Revival, Inside and Out
This isn’t a house wearing “Victorian” as a marketing label. The exterior shows the real hallmarks of Gothic Revival design: a steeply pitched slate roof, pointed arch windows, ornate decorative trim, a stone foundation, and classic clapboard siding. It’s the kind of facade that architecture buffs stop the car for.
Built in 1870, the home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms (one full, one three-quarter) across 1,989 square feet of interior living space, sitting on a 0.42-acre in-town lot.
Inside the Home
The interior leans into the formality and warmth of its era while offering practical, everyday livability:
- A first-floor primary bedroom — a genuine rarity in homes this old, and a huge plus for buyers wanting to avoid stairs
- An updated kitchen with a breakfast nook
- A formal dining room and a separate parlor, ideal for entertaining or simply preserving that old-house charm
- Spacious living areas with a mix of hardwood and carpet flooring
- A basement with interior entry access
The Carriage House
One of the standout extras here is the carriage house — offering ample storage space and room for vehicles. For a property this age, having a dedicated outbuilding already in place (rather than needing to add one) is a meaningful bonus, whether it’s used for parking, a workshop, or extra storage.
What to Know About the Systems
Buyers should note the home uses hot water heating with no central air conditioning, which is common for homes of this vintage in Vermont’s climate. On the upside, the electrical service has already been upgraded to 200+ amps, and the property is connected to public sewer — two of the more expensive upgrades already handled for you.
Why It’s Getting So Much Attention
Homes that combine authentic 19th-century architecture with day-to-day livability — a first-floor bedroom, an updated kitchen, upgraded electrical — don’t come up often, especially in a compact, walkable Vermont village setting. That combination likely explains why this listing has racked up nearly 14,000 views and over a thousand saves in less than three weeks.
For anyone who has been searching for a genuine, well-preserved piece of Gothic Revival architecture that doesn’t require a full gut renovation to be livable, 261 Church Street is worth a serious look — and given the traffic it’s already getting, probably sooner rather than later.
From ZIllow
Listing details sourced from Zillow, 261 Church St, Poultney, VT 05764. Listing agent: Suanne M Ohl, Northland Real Estate (MLS #5103278).
