Not every historic home needs six figures and a decade of patience to become someone’s dream project. This 1927 Peel-Lindsley Colonial Revival in Williamston, North Carolina just hit the market at $92,500, and the numbers suggest buyers are already circling it — the listing has pulled in nearly 6,700 views in just three weeks and is projected to sell faster than 97% of comparable nearby properties.
The Basics
Sitting near downtown Williamston on a 0.28-acre lot, the home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, built in 1927. Annual property taxes come in low at just $730 (2024), which helps soften the cost of the renovation work ahead.
Filled With History and Character
The listing doesn’t shy away from what makes this home special: original hardwood floors, detailed moldings, and the kind of architectural character that simply doesn’t get built anymore. A grand staircase greets you in the foyer, and a main-level bedroom features tongue-and-groove pine walls with built-in shelving — the sort of craftsmanship that would cost a fortune to replicate today.
Other standout details include:
- A fireplace, currently closed off but original to the home
- An updated kitchen with a custom porcelain sink and a walk-in pantry
- A full bathroom downstairs
- A koi pond and a detached outbuilding in the yard
What’s Already Been Done
Here’s the good news for buyers nervous about a full renovation: the roof was already replaced in 2025. That’s one of the biggest-ticket items on any old-house project list, and it’s already checked off.
What Still Needs Work
To be clear, this is billed honestly as a home needing “repairs and a little TLC,” not a turnkey purchase. Buyers should budget for:
- Installing a full HVAC system (heating and cooling are not currently in place)
- Replacing kitchen appliances
- Repairing the upstairs bathroom
For a buyer comfortable tackling those projects — or bringing in a contractor — the combination of a new roof, original architectural details, and a sub-$100K price tag is a rare one.
Why This One Won’t Last
With historic character, a recently replaced roof, and a price point nearly $200K below what a fully renovated home in the area might fetch, it’s easy to see why this listing is outperforming the local market. At $92,500, this is the kind of project house that tends to attract multiple offers fast — especially from buyers looking to build equity through renovation rather than pay a premium for move-in-ready.
Full detais under album below
From the Zillow listing:, 318 W Church St, Williamston, NC 27892. Listing agent: Elisha Faye Hardison, Sweetwater Real Estate Inc.
